New York Pasta Garden | Romantic Restaurants in Key West, Florida
© New York Pasta Garden
  • Please support our journalism through affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure
  • Written by our human editors, structured with the help of AI.

Review & FAQ:

The New York Pasta Garden brings a piece of the Big Apple down to Key West. A regular hang-out for locals, The New York Pasta Garden serves up classic Italian dishes. Guests can dine on huge family-style portions of baked and classic pastas, fresh seafood, and BBQ ribs or chicken. House entrees include hearty dishes of veal, steak, and chicken. The restaurant’s owner, Big John, moved from New York before opening his restaurant 25 years ago. He brings his passion for Italian cooking to a gorgeous island setting. Couples in town for a romantic holiday shouldn’t pass up a meal at this Key West favorite.

1075 Duval Street, Key West, FL, Phone: 305-292-1991

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

A & B Lobster House Prime Steakhouse Antonia's Azur Restaurant Bagatelle Cafe Marquesa Cafe Sole Grand Cafe Key West Hot Tin Roof Latitude's Restaurant Little Pearl Louie's Backyard New York Pasta Garden Nine One Five Santiago's Bodega Sunset Pier at Zero Duval Street Tavern N Town The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. Thirsty Mermaid

Explore more: Florida Keys > Romantic Restaurants in Key West, Florida

Plan Your Trip

Get Ready to Go!

Need some more help?


Go to travel reservations.