Romantic Restaurants in Key West, Florida

A & B Lobster House offers a romantic waterfront dining experience in Key West, where couples can enjoy a sunset meal while watching boats dock at the marina. This elegant seafood-focused restaurant is known for its refined atmosphere and fresh coastal fare.

Recommended For: Romantic dinners, seafood aficionados, and anyone seeking an elegant evening with marina views.

• Start with indulgent appetizers like lobster and crab cakes or clam chowder.
• Savor standout entrées such as butter-poached Florida lobster tail.
• Choose from a variety of expertly prepared steaks for non-seafood options.
• Admire scenic views of docked boats from the waterside dining room.
• Dine nightly in a refined setting perfect for special occasions.

A & B Lobster House, 700 Front Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-294-5880

Prime Steakhouse is a go-to destination in Key West for meat lovers seeking premium cuts in an elegant yet relaxed setting. Guests can enjoy a perfectly prepared sirloin, filet, or prime cut, paired with a bold red wine or expertly crafted martini.

Recommended For: Steak connoisseurs, upscale date nights, and guests seeking a refined dinner with surf-and-turf options.

• Choose from expertly grilled sirloin, prime cuts, or tender filets.
• Pair your entrée with a rich red wine or signature martini from the bar.
• Order seafood starters like oysters Rockefeller or jumbo crab cakes.
• Customize your meal with decadent sides like truffled macaroni and smoked gouda.
• Dine nightly in an elegant atmosphere with relaxed island charm.

Prime Steakhouse, 951 Caroline Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-296-4000

Antonia’s Key West is a charming Italian restaurant perfect for a romantic Sunday brunch, leisurely afternoon meal, or elegant dinner in the heart of Duval Street. Known for its warm hospitality and refined cuisine, Antonia’s offers a menu full of classic Italian favorites, including handmade pastas, succulent meats, and an impressive array of fresh seafood dishes.

Recommended For: Couples, wine lovers, and anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine with coastal flair in a romantic setting.

• Feast on handmade pastas and an extensive variety of seafood entrees.
• Enjoy award-winning wines that pair beautifully with every dish.
• Relax in a cozy atmosphere ideal for brunch, lunch, or candlelit dinners.
• Savor traditional Italian desserts like tiramisu and key lime pie.
• Dine daily with the ease of online reservations and central Duval Street access.

Antonia’s Key West, 615 Duval Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-294-6565

Azur Restaurant is a charming Mediterranean-inspired dining spot located in Old Town Key West, offering a relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere perfect for romantic brunches or intimate dinners. Guests can dine on the shaded outdoor terrace or inside the recently remodeled dining room. Chef-owner Michael Mosi, originally from Pittsburgh with Italian and Hungarian heritage, brings a diverse culinary background to the table, blending European techniques with fresh, local ingredients.

• Enjoy fresh Mediterranean fare in a beautifully shaded outdoor terrace or modern indoor space.
• Taste a creative fusion of European culinary techniques and local Key West ingredients.
• Meet Chef Michael Mosi’s unique vision influenced by his Italian-Hungarian roots.
• Dine on flavorful dishes perfect for a sunny brunch or romantic evening meal.
• Visit daily for brunch from 9–3 or return for dinner from 5:30–10 PM.

Azur Restaurant, 425 Grinnell Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-292-2987

Bagatelle Island Restaurant is a romantic and historic dining destination located near Mallory Square in the heart of downtown Key West. Housed in a beautifully preserved 19th-century mansion that was transformed into a restaurant in 1979, Bagatelle offers charming outdoor dining with live music and a breezy, tropical ambiance.

Recommended For: Romantic brunches, history buffs, and anyone seeking inventive island cuisine with a scenic Key West vibe.

• Dine in a historic 19th-century mansion just steps from Mallory Square.
• Experience creative American-Caribbean dishes with global influences.
• Enjoy daily brunch and romantic evenings with live music on the patio.
• Explore a menu crafted by Executive Chef David Zingg, inspired by world cuisines.
• Relax in an elegant yet laid-back setting perfect for couples and celebrations.

Bagatelle Island Restaurant, 115 Duval Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-296-6609

Cafe Marquesa is a Zagat-rated gem in Key West, renowned for its intimate ambiance and refined contemporary American cuisine. Loved by both locals and visitors, this elegant spot is perfect for a romantic dinner featuring seasonally inspired dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients. Guests can enjoy fresh seafood, expertly seared meats, and house-baked breads in the softly lit dining room.

Recommended For: Romantic evenings, fine dining enthusiasts, and anyone seeking an elevated culinary experience in Key West.

• Dine on fresh, seasonally driven dishes in an intimate, upscale setting.
• Enjoy seafood, meats, and breads made with care and top-quality ingredients.
• Relax at the bar with small plates and an expertly curated wine list.
• Experience cuisine crafted under the influence of the late Anthony Bourdain.
• Celebrate a special night at one of Key West’s highest-rated restaurants.

Cafe Marquesa, 600 Fleming Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-292-1244

Cafe Sole is a celebrated Key West dining gem founded in 1995 by Chef John Correa and his wife Judy. Tucked away from the busy tourist paths, this intimate restaurant blends French culinary artistry with the bounty of local seafood. Chef Correa’s refined menu highlights everything from conch carpaccio and crab cakes to grilled shrimp and bacon-wrapped dates.

Recommended For: Seafood enthusiasts, vegetarians, and couples seeking refined cuisine in a quiet, romantic Key West setting.

• Savor French-influenced dishes made with fresh, locally sourced seafood.
• Choose from a dedicated vegetarian menu with flavorful, satisfying options.
• Indulge in savory appetizers like bacon-wrapped dates and conch carpaccio.
• Finish with a slice of their famous Key lime pie or another house-made dessert.
• Discover a charming off-the-beaten-path restaurant recognized for excellence by Zagat.

Cafe Sole, 1029 Southard Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-294-0230

Grand Cafe Key West is a centrally located gem on lively Duval Street, just steps from eclectic shops and colorful art galleries. Known for its perfectly prepared steaks and fresh seafood, this inviting bistro is ideal for both casual lunches and elegant dinners.

Recommended For: Happy hour enthusiasts, seafood and steak lovers, and anyone seeking a centrally located dining spot with charm and variety.

• Start with flavorful small plates like spicy mussels or conch fritters.
• Feast on generously portioned entrées like seafood pasta and roasted veal shank.
• Unwind with drink and food specials during daily happy hour.
• Dine early to enjoy sunset-ready pre-set dinner specials.
• Explore vibrant Duval Street before or after your meal in this art-filled district.

Grand Cafe Key West, 314 Duval Street, Key West, FL
Phone: 305-292-4740