Romantic Restaurants in Indianapolis

Nestled in an 1880s log home between Meridian Street and the Indiana Central Canal, Meridian Restaurant & Bar is one of Indianapolis’ most charming date-night destinations. Guests dine on refined American fare while gazing out at the historic neighborhoods or the leafy serenity of Alice Carter Park. Inside, flickering fireplaces and exposed beams add to the romantic ambiance—especially at dinner.

Highlights:

• Located in a beautifully restored 1880s log home
• Fine dining American cuisine for lunch and dinner
• Romantic indoor setting with a cozy fireplace
• Craft cocktails and martinis served at the intimate bar
• Private dining room available for small gatherings and celebrations

Pro Tip:

Book a table near the window or fireplace for the most romantic vibe—and don’t skip the specialty cocktail list for a standout martini or seasonal sipper.

Meridian Restaurant & Bar
5694 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-466-1111
meridianonmeridian.com

A local favorite since 1951, Capri Restaurant brings the heart of Italy to the northside of Indianapolis. Known for its authentic Italian flavors and elegant atmosphere, Capri serves up a traditional multi-course dining experience—starting with antipasti, moving into rich, homemade pastas, and finishing with flavorful entrées featuring veal, chicken, beef, and fresh fish. Whether you're in for date night or planning a family celebration, Capri delivers timeless hospitality and unforgettable meals.

Highlights:

• Serving authentic Italian cuisine since 1951
• Homemade pastas, fresh seafood, and classic meat dishes
• Warm, traditional dining space perfect for special occasions
• Private events and weddings hosted onsite
• Catering available with full-service staff and customized menus

Pro Tip:

Go hungry—and save room for the secondi. The veal and fish dishes are house specialties, and the wine list pairs beautifully with just about everything.

Capri Restaurant
2602 Ruth Drive, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-259-4122
capriindianapolis.com

A true Indianapolis institution, St. Elmo Steak House has been serving unforgettable meals since 1902, making it the oldest steakhouse in the city. Named after the patron saint of sailors, this downtown gem still boasts much of its original Chicago-style saloon charm, enhanced by a multi-million dollar renovation that added luxurious private dining rooms, a wine cellar, and the stylish 1933 Lounge. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic evening filled with prime steaks, fresh seafood, and expertly crafted cocktails.

Highlights:

• Established in 1902 and rich with historic charm
• Famous for steaks, chops, seafood, and legendary shrimp cocktail
• Renovated interiors include a wine cellar and elegant private rooms
• Classic cocktail service in the cozy upstairs 1933 Lounge
• One of the most iconic dining destinations in Indianapolis

Pro Tip:

Order the world-famous shrimp cocktail to start—it’s known for its extra-spicy horseradish kick. Then head up to the 1933 Lounge for a nightcap in a timeless setting.

St. Elmo Steak House
127 South Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-635-0636
stelmos.com

Unique Restaurants

A delicious blend of dining and wine culture, Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant offers a full sensory experience just north of downtown Indianapolis. Guests can start with a stroll through the barrel room before sampling handcrafted wines in the tasting room, then head into the dining space for a refined meal paired with the perfect pour. The extensive wine list features everything from sparkling selections and crisp whites to bold reds and global varietals. The bar menu also serves up craft cocktails and signature sangrias for added flair.

Highlights:

• On-site tasting room, bar, and upscale dining experience
• Full wine list with house-crafted varietals and global bottles
• Sangrias, specialty cocktails, and food pairing suggestions
• Private event space with pricing available online
• Wine club memberships with exclusive rewards and tastings

Pro Tip:

Join the Cooper’s Hawk Wine Club for monthly bottle perks and access to new releases. Don't skip the wine pairing recommendations on the menu—they’re spot on.

Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant
3815 East 96th Street, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-574-9463
chwinery.com

For a vibrant fusion of Latin flavors and contemporary style, head to Delicia in the heart of Indianapolis. This stylish spot blends the best of Latin American, Caribbean, and Spanish cuisines, offering everything from crab and shrimp terrine to gooey baked cheese with chorizo. The main courses deliver flavorful takes on classic dishes like empanadas, enchiladas, and fish tacos. And if you have a sweet tooth, the house-made churros, flan, and tres leches cake will hit the spot.

Highlights:

• Modern Latin fusion cuisine with global inspiration
• Menu features Caribbean, Spanish, and Latin American favorites
• Rum- and tequila-based cocktails crafted in-house
• Sunday brunch and private event options available
• Inventive appetizers and decadent Latin desserts

Pro Tip:

Try one of their signature tequila cocktails and save room for dessert—the tres leches and flan are local legends. Sunday brunch is also a hidden gem.

Delicia
5215 North College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-925-0677
deliciaindy.com

For a luxurious evening of fine dining and perfectly cooked steaks, Eddie Merlot’s Indianapolis delivers an elevated experience. This high-end steakhouse chain is known for its prime-aged beef, fresh seafood, and indulgent sides, all served in a sophisticated, modern space. Whether you're in the mood for king crab, filet mignon, or a crafted cocktail, this is the place to go all out. Vegetarian-friendly options are also available, and the attentive service makes it ideal for anniversaries, celebrations, or client dinners.

Highlights:

• Premium aged steaks, seafood, and king crab
• Signature handcrafted cocktails and curated wine list
• Upscale setting perfect for special occasions
• Vegetarian-friendly dishes available
• Platinum Club loyalty program with wine tastings and perks

Pro Tip:

Sign up for the Platinum Club if you’re a regular—you’ll earn points and receive birthday rewards, exclusive tastings, and members-only invites.

Eddie Merlot’s Indianapolis
3645 East 96th Street, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-846-8303
eddiemerlots.com

Restaurants for a Date

A visit to Iozzo’s Garden of Italy in downtown Indianapolis feels like stepping into a charming Italian trattoria. Established in 1930, the restaurant blends old-world ambiance with modern comfort—think exposed brick, vintage photos, and soft lighting. Guests can enjoy classic Italian fare indoors or dine al fresco in the inviting garden courtyard. From house-made pastas and wood-fired pizzas to hearty meat dishes, the menu is full of time-honored recipes passed down from Calabria. The bar serves an impressive wine list and signature cocktails with Italian roots.

Highlights:

• Family-owned Italian restaurant dating back to 1930
• Romantic courtyard dining available
• Classic dishes including pizza, pasta, salads, and meat entrees
• Extensive wine list and handcrafted Italian cocktails
• Perfect for date nights, group dinners, and special occasions

Pro Tip:

Ask for a table in the courtyard on a warm evening for the most romantic experience. And don’t miss the Calabrian cocktail specials—a nod to the family’s roots.

Iozzo’s Garden of Italy
946 South Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-974-1100
iozzos.com

Who says you have to leave the Midwest to experience the bold flavors of Latin America? Livery brings the taste of South America straight to downtown Indianapolis with a modern menu and vibrant atmosphere. Set in a stylish space with warm wood, cool stone, and cozy lighting, Livery is perfect for date night or catching up with friends. Empanadas, ceviche, oysters, tacos, and grilled specialties fill the menu, while the bar pours a standout margarita alongside Caribbean and South American-inspired cocktails.

Highlights:

• Latin American cuisine in a modern, rustic-chic setting
• Popular menu items include ceviche, empanadas, and tacos
• Signature margaritas and tropical cocktails at the full bar
• Romantic, date-worthy vibe with stylish design
• Second location available in South Bend, Indiana

Pro Tip:

Start with the ceviche and split a few tacos for the table. The pineapple mezcal margarita is a must-try, especially on a warm evening.

Livery
720 North College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-383-0330
livery-restaurant.com

Step into a little slice of Tuscany right in the heart of Indianapolis at Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant. Housed in a charming villa-style building, this romantic, highly rated eatery serves up classic Mediterranean and Italian fare inspired by family traditions. Though Mama Carolla hails from Omaha, she brought her dream of rustic Italian hospitality to life here in the Midwest. Guests enjoy a warm, vintage ambiance along with house wines by the carafe, hearty pastas, seafood, meat dishes, and Mama’s signature specialties. It’s no surprise Mama Carolla’s has been named one of the 10 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis by USA Today Travel.

Highlights:

• Rustic Italian villa ambiance with old-country charm
• Classic pastas, seafood, meats, and Mama’s house specialties
• House wine served by the half carafe, full carafe, or bottle
• Listed among USA Today’s 10 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis
• Perfect for romantic evenings or special celebrations

Pro Tip:

Ask about Mama’s specialty of the day and grab a seat on the patio when the weather’s nice—it feels like dining in a Tuscan courtyard.

Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant
1031 East 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN
Phone: 317-259-9412
mamacarollas.com