Nantucket isn’t just a place—it’s a feeling. Cobblestone streets meet windswept beaches, and history hums softly behind every weathered shingle. Whether you're sipping wine by the harbor or waking to the sound of gulls and tide, this island has a way of slowing time and deepening connection. These handpicked Nantucket hotels offer the perfect backdrop for honeymoons, romantic weekends, or any moment that deserves to be unforgettable.
Best Nantucket Hotels
New England charm wrapped in seaside warmth at The Nantucket Hotel and Resort
The Nantucket Hotel and Resort felt like stepping into a coastal storybook—where everything was both timeless and quietly indulgent. Mornings came with soft fog lifting over the harbor, and evenings felt like summer’s golden hour was holding on just a little longer. I remember thinking, "This is the kind of place where time remembers how to slow down."
What I Loved Most: Riding the hotel’s vintage fire truck through cobblestone streets, the wind salty and warm as we waved like kids again.
My highlights? Dinner at Breeze Restaurant, tucked inside the hotel. I had the pan-seared scallops with sweet corn purée and crispy pancetta. The flavors were coastal, clean, and comforting—perfectly Nantucket.
Travel Tips:
- Location: Just a short walk from downtown Nantucket
- Vibe: Family-friendly, polished, nostalgic
- Highlights: Pools, fire truck rides, full-service spa, kid-friendly touches
- Best Time to Visit: June–September for peak charm and beach weather
- Cost: Luxury pricing with seasonal packages
- Address: 77 Easton Street, Nantucket, MA 02554
Harbor views and barefoot luxury at White Elephant
From the moment we arrived, White Elephant whispered quiet luxury in every detail—crisp linens, soft sea breezes, and that unmistakable Nantucket light pouring through every window. The harbor felt like a living painting, and we let ourselves sink into its rhythm. I remember thinking, "This is what effortless elegance really feels like."
What I Loved Most: Lounging on the lawn with wine and a blanket, watching sailboats drift by as if on cue.
My highlights? Lunch at Brant Point Grill, right by the water. I had the lobster roll—overstuffed and buttery, served with hand-cut fries and a view worth lingering over. The sea air and slow pace made it all taste like summer.
Travel Tips:
- Location: Waterfront in downtown Nantucket
- Vibe: Upscale, relaxed, romantic
- Highlights: Harbor views, spa, complimentary bikes and shuttles
- Best Time to Visit: Late spring through early fall for best weather
- Cost: Premium waterfront luxury
- Address: 50 Easton Street, Nantucket, MA 02554
Live the Harbor Life at The Cottages of the Nantucket Boat Basin
Staying at The Cottages at Nantucket Boat Basin felt like becoming part of the harbor itself. Surrounded by gentle sway, creaking docks, and the occasional seagull cry, we woke each day with the water right outside our door. I remember thinking, "This is what it feels like to stay inside a postcard."
What I Loved Most: Sipping coffee on the deck of our marina suite while fishermen readied their boats and the sun painted ripples across the harbor.
My highlights? Dinner at Cru, just a stroll along the waterfront. I had oysters on the half shell followed by butter-poached lobster and chilled rosé. Every bite echoed the mood of the marina—fresh, elegant, and alive with sea air.
Travel Tips:
- Location: On the waterfront, steps from Nantucket’s historic district
- Vibe: Nautical, private, casual-chic
- Highlights: Marina views, pet-friendly options, private decks
- Best Time to Visit: Late spring through September
- Cost: Mid-to-high, depending on location along the dock
- Address: 1 Swain Wharf, Nantucket, MA 02554
Step Into Nantucket’s Storied Past With a Stay at Jared Coffin House
Walking into the Jared Coffin House felt like stepping into another century—wrought iron, hardwoods, quiet corners filled with old soul. And yet, it wrapped us in comfort, not formality. I remember thinking, "Some places don’t age—they just deepen."
What I Loved Most: Sitting by the fireplace in the evening with a glass of wine, the inn hushed and glowing as the island slept beyond the windows.
My highlights? A candlelit dinner at Tree Bar, just across the courtyard. I had pan-seared halibut with fennel and a citrus beurre blanc, paired with a crisp Sauvignon Blanc. It was refined but still warm, much like the house itself.
Travel Tips:
- Location: Centrally located in Nantucket town
- Vibe: Historic, cozy, elegant
- Highlights: Antique furnishings, library lounge, excellent walkability
- Best Time to Visit: Spring or fall for fewer crowds
- Cost: Moderate-to-luxury, depending on room and season
- Address: 29 Broad Street, Nantucket, MA 02554
Enjoy Classic Comfort at the Nantucket Inn
Tucked just outside the buzz of downtown, The Nantucket Inn gave us space to breathe and a warm smile with every interaction. It felt like staying with a thoughtful friend—laid-back, sunny, and always ready with coffee. I remember thinking, "Comfort doesn’t have to shout—it just has to show up."
What I Loved Most: Lounging by the garden pool in the late afternoon, reading while dragonflies skimmed across the water.
My highlights? A homemade-style breakfast buffet in the sunny dining room. I had scrambled eggs, local berry preserves on toast, and coffee that kept refilling before I even noticed it was low. It was simple, sincere, and exactly right.
Travel Tips:
- Location: Near the airport, short drive or shuttle to town
- Vibe: Inviting, easygoing, classic island hospitality
- Highlights: Indoor and outdoor pools, tennis courts, complimentary shuttle
- Best Time to Visit: Summer for full resort access
- Cost: More affordable than waterfront options
- Address: 1 Miller Lane, Nantucket, MA 02554
If Secluded Beaches Inspire You, Escape to The Wauwinet
At The Wauwinet, it felt like the world grew very quiet—in the best way. The property stretched between the Atlantic and the bay, and every moment seemed designed for stillness, intimacy, and wonder. I remember thinking, "This is what it means to be truly away."
What I Loved Most: Watching the sun rise over the Atlantic and set over the bay—all from the same lawn chair.
My highlights? A sunset dinner at TOPPER'S, the on-site restaurant. I had the butter-poached lobster with heirloom carrots and truffle vinaigrette. The elegance of it all—the breeze, the clink of glasses, the hush of waves—was something I’ll never forget.
Travel Tips:
- Location: Eastern edge of Nantucket, near Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge
- Vibe: Refined, quiet, exclusive
- Highlights: Private beach, bay and ocean views, fine dining
- Best Time to Visit: June through September for the full coastal experience
- Cost: High-end luxury pricing
- Address: 120 Wauwinet Road, Nantucket, MA 02584
When the Island Calls You Back
Each stay in Nantucket leaves you with more than photos—it lingers like a memory whispered on salt air. From the historic halls of the Jared Coffin House to the seaside stillness of The Wauwinet, these properties offer more than luxury. They offer space to be present, to feel deeply, and to fall in love with both the island and each other. Wherever you choose to stay, let Nantucket remind you how beautiful the quiet can be.
More to Explore