Restaurants in Sarasota, Florida

Big Water Fish Market is a hidden gem on Siesta Key, located in the Crescent Beach Shopping Center. Specializing in fresh, Florida-caught seafood, the market also offers a casual dining menu and delicious takeout options.

We Recommend This For: Seafood lovers, casual diners, families, and anyone who enjoys fresh, local flavors in a relaxed atmosphere.

What we Love: Fresh, local seafood, BYOB policy, delicious takeout options, and the casual vibe.

• Grab fresh fish, seafood, and produce for home cooking, or enjoy a casual meal in-store.
• Enjoy a simple but tasty menu that highlights the market's best seafood.
• Relax at one of the picnic tables with family and friends for a seafood steam pot dinner.
• Support a local business committed to fresh, sustainably-sourced seafood and local community involvement.
• Bring your favorite drinks, as Big Water Fish Market has a BYOB policy!

Big Water Fish Market, 6641 Midnight Pass Road, Siesta Key, FL 34242
Phone: 941-554-8101

Antoine's Restaurant offers an elegant continental menu in a cozy, stylish setting. The artisanal menu features a variety of seafood, including PEI mussels served in seven different ways and lobster croquettes paired with a fresh salad.

We Recommend This For: Seafood lovers, food enthusiasts, and those seeking an elegant dining experience in Sarasota.

What we Love: Artisanal seafood dishes, welcoming atmosphere, and the delightful variety of preparations.

• Indulge in homemade creamed bisque and light waffles with blue cheese and arugula.
• Enjoy seared salmon, pan-fried scallops, and black grouper with a pesto crust.
• Relax in a cozy ambiance with a menu full of exquisite options for every palate.
• Pair your meal with a selection of beers, wine, or soft drinks to complement the cuisine.
• Experience attentive, friendly service in a charming, welcoming environment.

Antoine's Restaurant, 1100 N Tuttle Ave, Sarasota, Florida 34237
Phone: 941-331-1400

Yoder's Amish Restaurant has been a staple in Sarasota since 1975, offering hearty homemade comfort food in a warm, unpretentious setting. Known for its fresh, flavorful dishes and award-winning homemade pies, Yoder's is the perfect place for a family meal or a satisfying breakfast to start your day.

We Recommend This For: Families, comfort food lovers, and anyone seeking hearty Amish and American favorites in a cozy atmosphere.

What we Love: Hearty portions, homemade pies, and a classic, old-fashioned ambiance that brings people together.

• Enjoy delicious homemade comfort food like fried chicken, meatloaf, and country fried steak.
• Indulge in their famous, award-winning pies—perfect for dessert or a take-home treat.
• Shop at the Amish Village for a variety of specialty groceries, deli meats, cheeses, and baking supplies.
• Relax in a buzzing, family-friendly atmosphere that welcomes everyone with a home-cooked meal.
• Experience the charm of this local favorite and the surrounding Amish Village, which includes a gift shop and produce market.

Yoder's, Amish Village, 3434 Bahia Vista St., Sarasota, FL 34239
Phone: 941-955-7771

Selva Grill combines the exotic flavors of Latin American and North American fare to create mouthwatering Nuevo Latino cuisine, with an emphasis on Peruvian dishes. Offering a vibrant, casual atmosphere, Selva Grill takes diners on a culinary journey through Latin America, showcasing authentic dishes with innovative presentations.

We Recommend This For: Food adventurers, lovers of Latin American cuisine, and anyone seeking creative, flavorful dishes in a lively setting.

What we Love: The unique fusion of flavors, artistic dish presentations, and the fresh, inventive approach to Latin American cuisine.

• Savor the ceviches de la Casa, a uniquely flavored appetizer that captures the essence of Latin American cuisine.
• Indulge in signature entrées like fresh seafood and grilled meats with exotic salsas, herbs, and vegetables.
• Enjoy meticulously crafted dishes that are presented as works of art by the friendly and attentive staff.
• Relax in a vibrant and casual atmosphere while sipping on a refreshing Mojito or selecting from an extensive wine list.
• Pair your meal with wines from around the world, including rare vintages and signature cocktails.

Selva Grill, 1345 Main Street, Sarasota FL 34236
Phone: 941-362-4427

Duval's is an elegant seafood restaurant known for serving some of the freshest seafood and fish in Sarasota. With a focus on locally sourced ingredients, Duval's supports local fishermen and farmers, ensuring that every dish is made with the freshest catch of the day and produce.

We Recommend This For: Seafood enthusiasts, those who appreciate local, sustainable dining, and anyone seeking a refined dining experience with fresh, high-quality ingredients.

What we Love: The emphasis on local sourcing, the diverse seafood menu, and the elegant atmosphere perfect for any occasion.

• Indulge in signature dishes like blackened shrimp with carrot ribbons, Duval’s Seafood Sampler, and black pepper-encrusted salmon over spring greens.
• Experience the daily, fresh catch delivered straight from local waters and filleted in-house for the highest quality.
• Pair your meal with a selection from Duval’s extensive, constantly updated wine list, or enjoy cocktails and spirits to complement your seafood feast.
• Relax at lunch, dinner, or Sunday brunch in an elegant setting, with friendly service and a menu that highlights the best of the ocean.
• Support sustainable practices by dining at a restaurant that values local sourcing and freshness.

Duval's, 1435 Main Street, Sarasota, FL 34236
Phone: 941-312-4001

Cafe L'Europe has been serving authentic continental cuisine since 1973, offering diners in Sarasota an elegant European-inspired ambiance. Founded by European-born Titus Letschert, this fine dining restaurant combines superb cuisine, award-winning wines, handcrafted cocktails, and impeccable service for an unforgettable experience.

We Recommend This For: Fine dining enthusiasts, lovers of European cuisine, and those seeking an elegant, memorable dining experience on St. Armand’s Circle.

What we Love: The classic European ambiance, the exceptional menu, and the table-side preparation of signature dishes.

• Indulge in signature dishes like Lobster Bisque, Dover Sole Meunière, Brandied Duckling, and Chateaubriand, flame-grilled at the table.
• Enjoy an extensive selection of award-winning wines to perfectly complement your meal.
• Relax in a refined atmosphere that transports you to the elegance of a European dining experience.
• Experience flawless service and culinary artistry that elevates every meal into a special occasion.
• Savor the tradition of European hospitality with every dish, expertly prepared and presented.

Cafe L'Europe, 431 St. Armand's Circle, Sarasota, FL 34236
Phone: 941-388-4415

Columbia Restaurant Sarasota is part of the renowned Columbia Restaurant Group, founded by Casimiro Hernandez, Sr. in 1905. A favorite among locals and visitors alike, this historic restaurant serves an authentic menu of Spanish cuisine, offering a truly delectable dining experience in the heart of St. Armand’s Circle.

We Recommend This For: Fans of Spanish cuisine, those looking for a historic dining experience, and anyone craving fresh seafood or tender meats in a vibrant atmosphere.

What we Love: The rich history, the vibrant Spanish flavors, and the exceptional service that makes each meal memorable.

• Savor starters like Cuban Black Bean Soup, Gazpacho Andalucia, and tapas of Sliced Chorizo, tender baby pork ribs, and jumbo shrimp sautéed in extra-virgin Spanish olive oil.
• Indulge in fresh seafood options like red snapper, ahi tuna, and octopus, or enjoy meat dishes like steaks, ribs, chops, and chicken.
• Pair your meal with a selection from an extensive wine list, featuring exceptional wines from South America and Spain.
• Relax in a lively atmosphere, with service that reflects the restaurant’s longstanding family traditions.
• Experience the rich flavors of authentic Spanish cuisine, passed down through generations of the Hernandez family.

Columbia Restaurant Sarasota, 411 St Armands Cir, Sarasota, FL 34236
Phone: 941-388-3987