Key Largo’s food scene is going to surprise you in the best way (just like the beaches!). You’ll find everything from casual tiki bars to waterfront fine dining, with menus full of fresh seafood, tropical cocktails, and laid-back vibes. I always make it a point to plan my meals here. Eating in Key Largo feels like part of the vacation, not just a break between adventures.
Whether you’re craving a sunset dinner with your toes in the sand, a romantic Italian meal under the stars, or a dockside lunch after a morning out on the water, you’re going to find your spot. I’ve discovered some of my favorite meals in tiny marina cafés and colorful beachfront patios.
Best Restaurants in Key Largo, Florida:
Catch the Sunset and Island Flavors at Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar, Key Largo
If you’re headed to Key Largo, I really think you should grab a meal at Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar. It’s right at the Bayside Inn, and I go there any time I want great food with a front-row seat to the sunset. You’ll love the open-air vibe—it’s totally relaxed and has that breezy, coastal feel you can’t fake.
Recommended For: If you’re into seafood, sunsets, casual date nights, or just want a great meal while on vacation, I’d put this place on your list.
- Dine on fresh-caught fish, shellfish, juicy steaks, and pasta with housemade sauces—I’ve had all of the above and never been disappointed.
- Relax and take in the bay views—I always linger longer than I planned to because it’s just that peaceful.
- Unwind over a long lunch or time it right for dinner at sunset. You won’t want to rush this one.
- Enjoy the vegetarian options too—if that’s your thing, I’ve had their salads and veggie dishes and they’re super fresh and satisfying.
Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar, 99540 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-451-3380
If You’re Craving Italian Classics with a Keys Twist, Head to DiGiorgio's Cafe Largo
If you’re in the mood for Italian comfort food in Key Largo, I highly recommend DiGiorgio's Cafe Largo. It’s family-run and full of charm—you’ll feel like you’re walking into someone’s home the second you step inside. I always notice how the atmosphere is cozy, welcoming, and full of heart.
Recommended For: You’ll love it for romantic dinners, relaxed family meals, or anytime you’re craving old-school Italian flavors done right.
- Savor antipasti, Caprese salad, and bruschetta like I do to start—it really sets the tone for what’s coming.
- Delight in their housemade pastas and seafood entrées—I always leave full and happy.
- Enjoy a drink from their great selection of Italian wines, craft beers, or cocktails. You can ask for a pairing—they’re super helpful with suggestions.
- Indulge in dessert. Everything’s homemade, and trust me, you’ll want to save room.
- Relax in the warm, family-style setting. You’ll feel like part of the DiGiorgio family by the time you leave.
DiGiorgio's Cafe Largo, 99530 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-451-4885
Feast on Fresh Catch in a Laid-Back Setting at Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant
If you’re craving seafood in Key Largo, I always recommend Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant. You’ll love how fresh everything tastes—it’s one of those spots locals and visitors both keep coming back to. I also really enjoy the laid-back vibe, especially when I’m sitting out in their colorful tropical courtyard.
Recommended For: If you’re a seafood fan, dining with family, or just want a fun, Keys-style meal, you’re going to love it here.
- Dive into bold starters like Fried Cracked Conch, Wasabi Crusted Tuna, or Oysters Rockefeller—I always start with one of those and never regret it.
- Feast on their lobster, Catch-of-the-Day, or a juicy Ribeye if that’s more your style. I like switching it up every time I go.
- Customize your meal with their “cook your catch” option. If you’ve been out fishing, this is where I’d bring your haul—it’s always a hit.
- Relax in the tropical courtyard or grab a cozy table indoors when the weather’s not cooperating. Either way, I always feel comfortable and well taken care of.
- Accommodates everyone in your group—even if someone doesn’t love seafood. I’ve brought friends who were happy with their steak, chicken, or vegetarian plates.
Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant, 102770 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-451-0565
Date Ideas:
Dine Like a Local at Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge
If you’re in the mood for a relaxed but elevated dinner near the water, I always suggest Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge. You’ll find it right on the marina, and I love how it blends Mediterranean flavors with a laid-back Keys setting. Whether you sit inside, on the patio, or under the covered terrace, you’re in for gorgeous waterfront views.
Recommended For: I’d say this is perfect if you’re dining as a couple, with family, or just want to treat yourself to upscale Mediterranean food without feeling too formal.
- Begin your meal with a few small plates
- Indulge in one of their standout entrées. I’ve had the New York Strip au Poivre and the Scallops de Provence, and both were rich, flavorful, and beautifully plated.
- Savor whatever’s on their seasonal menu—it’s always fresh and full of Mediterranean flair. I love discovering something new each time I go.
- Relax while taking in those marina views. You’ll feel like you’re tucked away somewhere special, especially as the sun starts to set.
- Enjoy something from the bar—whether it’s a cold draft beer, a crisp international wine, or a cocktail, I always find the drinks just right for a chill night out.
Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge, 90311 Old Hwy, Tavernier, FL 33070
Phone: 305-852-6012
If You Want Dockside Dining and a Breezy Vibe, Drop Anchor at Skipper's Dockside
If you’re looking for oceanfront dining with a fun, tropical twist, I always tell friends to head to Skipper's Dockside at Mile Marker 100. You’ll love the waterfront views, especially from their tiki hut bar—it’s the kind of place where I can kick back and feel like I’m on vacation, even if I’m not.
Recommended For: I think it’s perfect if you love seafood, are planning a date night, or want to hang out with a group somewhere festive and full of local charm.
- Start with something fresh.
- Feast on their seasonal menu. I usually go with the Shrimp Po’ Boy or the Herb-Roasted Chicken—hearty, flavorful, and just right by the water.
- Enjoy your drinks at the tiki bar. You can grab a cold craft beer, sip on a cocktail, or try something new from their wine list. I like mixing it up depending on the mood.
- Relax with live music and soak in the marina views. The mix of tropical energy and vintage decor always puts me in a good mood.
- Visit any day for lunch or dinner—I’ve never had a bad time no matter when I go.
Skipper's Dockside, 528 Caribbean Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-453-9794
Savor Tropical Cuisine Under the Palms at Snook's Bayside Restaurant & Grand Tiki
If you’re chasing the perfect sunset in Key Largo, I always tell people to head straight to Snook's Bayside Restaurant & Grand Tiki. You’ll feel the tropical vibes as soon as you walk in, and the energy just builds from there. I love how they turn every sunset into a celebration—it’s such a fun tradition.
Recommended For: If you’re into cocktails, sunsets, or want a festive waterfront dinner with your partner or a group of friends, you’re going to love it here.
- Celebrate the sunset with everyone else—when the horn sounds. It’s such a cool touch on their massive 5,000 sq ft patio.
- Unwind at the Grand Tiki Bar. You’ll love the granite counters, bamboo details, and flickering tiki torches—I usually grab a drink and just soak it all in.
- Dine on whatever’s fresh that day—I like their seafood, but the prime steaks are just as tempting. Whether it’s lunch or dinner, I’ve always had a great meal here.
- Choose your vibe—I’ve eaten indoors when I wanted something a little more polished, but the outdoor lounge is where I go when I want to fully lean into island time.
- Visit any day of the week. I’ve gone on both weekdays and weekends, and the waterfront views and laid-back atmosphere never disappoint.
Snook's Bayside Restaurant & Grand Tiki, 99470 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-453-5004
Unwind in Coastal Chic Style at Sol by the Sea
If you’re dreaming of a romantic beachside dinner with a view, I always recommend Sol by the Sea at Playa Largo Resort. You’ll love the coastal-chic vibe—it’s got that rustic beach shack feel, but with a touch of luxury that makes every visit feel special. I go there when I want great food, a laid-back setting, and those unforgettable sunset views.
Recommended For: If you’re staying at the resort, planning a date night, or just want a tropical meal with toes-in-the-sand energy, I think you’ll absolutely love it.
- Dine in their breezy, pastel-toned space right on the pier. I’m a sucker for the driftwood decor and white-washed tables. It sets the perfect island mood.
- Savor Caribbean-inspired dishes made with fresh, seasonal ingredients. Whether you go for seafood, steak, chicken, or a colorful salad, I’ve always been impressed with the flavor and presentation.
- Indulge in one of their handcrafted cocktails while the sun sets—it’s one of my favorite happy hour spots. You’ll also find great beers and easygoing wines if that’s more your thing.
- Relax with a view that feels like a painting. I always take a deep breath here—it’s quiet, peaceful, and just the kind of place that makes you want to stay longer.
- Visit for lunch or dinner, any day of the week. I’ve gone for both, and you really can’t go wrong with the timing—the setting always delivers.
Sol by the Sea, 97450 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-853-1001
If Sunset Dinners Are Your Thing, Don’t Miss Sundowners, Key Largo
If you want to catch one of the best sunsets in the Keys, I always tell people to grab a table at Sundowners in Key Largo. I’ve been going since forever, and it’s still my go-to for a relaxed dinner with an unbeatable view over Florida Bay. You’ll love the glass-walled dining room—it feels like the sunset is putting on a private show just for you.
Recommended For: If you’re planning a romantic dinner, looking for great seafood, or meeting friends for a sunset meal, I really think you’ll love it here.
- Dine on super-fresh seafood. Go for the lump crabmeat, lobster bisque, or the sautéed shrimp and lobster. You can taste the quality in every bite.
- Enjoy more than just seafood too. I’ve had their prime steaks, sandwiches, and salads, and they’re just as satisfying. If you’re vegetarian, you’ll find solid options too.
- Indulge in one of their weekly specials. I personally love Fish Fry Fridays (all-you-can-eat!) and Prime Rib Saturdays—you’ve got to come hungry.
- Relax on the deck or patio with a craft beer or tropical cocktail. I’ve lost track of time just hanging out with a drink in hand and that perfect view.
- Visit anytime for lunch or dinner. They’re open every day, and I honestly think there’s no bad time to go—it’s always a good idea.
Sundowners, 103900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-451-4502
Relax with Waterfront Views and Caribbean Flavors at The Buzzard's Roost Restaurant
If you’re in Key Largo and want a laid-back waterfront spot with great seafood and good vibes, I always recommend The Buzzard's Roost Restaurant. You’ll find it tucked away in Garden Cove Marina, and I love how peaceful it feels compared to the busier spots. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back, listen to live music, and just enjoy the view.
Recommended For: You’ll love it if you're craving seafood by the water, planning a casual date night, or looking for live music or a fun Sunday brunch with steel drums.
- Start with a drink at the tiki bar. If you're there on Sunday, the steel drums set the perfect mood.
- Dive into something fresh—I’m a fan of the fish tacos and fried shrimp baskets, but they also serve a great steak and hearty pastas if you're in the mood for something different.
- Pair your meal with a cold craft beer, a glass of wine, or one of their fun cocktails. I like to try something new from the bar every time I go.
- Treat yourself to dessert—I always save room for their house-made ice cream. It’s the kind of sweet ending that makes the whole meal feel even better.
- Join them for lunch, dinner, or that relaxed Sunday brunch. No matter when you go, you’ll be treated to peaceful water views and easygoing service.
The Buzzard's Roost Restaurant, 21 Garden Cove Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: 305-453-3746
Jump to a Spot...
- • Catch the Sunset and Island Flavors at Bayside Grille & Sunset Bar, Key Largo
- • If You’re Craving Italian Classics with a Keys Twist, Head to DiGiorgio's Cafe Largo
- • Feast on Fresh Catch in a Laid-Back Setting at Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant
- • Dine Like a Local at Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge
- • If You Want Dockside Dining and a Breezy Vibe, Drop Anchor at Skipper's Dockside
- • Savor Tropical Cuisine Under the Palms at Snook's Bayside Restaurant & Grand Tiki
- • Unwind in Coastal Chic Style at Sol by the Sea
- • If Sunset Dinners Are Your Thing, Don’t Miss Sundowners, Key Largo
- • Relax with Waterfront Views and Caribbean Flavors at The Buzzard's Roost Restaurant