Restaurants on Long Island serve up a feast of flavors: ocean-fresh seafood, vineyard-side elegance, and cozy spots tucked in historic towns. It’s where I chase sunsets with a fork in hand, savoring every coastal breeze and plateful of local pride.
I’ve got buttery lobster ravioli in front of me, a chilled North Fork chardonnay, and the soft hum of conversation as boats drift by—right here on beautiful Long Island, New York. Who knew fine dining could feel so relaxed and effortless?
"Salt air, bold flavors, and small-town charm with big-time taste? This is Long Island’s culinary vibe!"
This is Why I Keep Coming Back for More:
Unique Long Island Restaurants:
1. Feast on Seafood Favorites at Bostwick’s Chowder House
I like:
"Lobster rolls, clam chowder, and beachy vibes make this East Hampton staple a summer must."
Bostwick’s Chowder House has been a beloved Hamptons favorite for the past two decades, offering a laid-back, beachy atmosphere perfect for savoring some of the region’s freshest seafood.
Recommended For: Seafood lovers, beachgoers seeking a relaxed dining spot, families, and anyone craving chowder, lobster rolls, or the fresh daily catch in a no-frills setting.
- Dig into steaming bowls of rich, hearty chowder or a classic, buttery lobster roll.
- Order a basket of crispy fried clams or explore the daily catch, which might include swordfish, halibut, mako, or tuna.
- Unwind with a cold beer or one of Bostwick’s famously giant and delicious cocktails.
- Relax in the breezy, beach-themed space that embraces a paper-plate casual charm.
- Visit during the warmer months — Bostwick’s closes for the winter season.
Bostwick’s Chowder House, 277 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937
Phone: 631-324-1111
2. Dine Waterside in Tranquility at Mill Pond
I recommend:
"Overlooking the scenic pond in Center Moriches, this spot blends elegant dishes with relaxed waterfront charm."
Mill Pond in Centerport offers a romantic dining experience with stunning views of Mill Pond and breathtaking sunsets, whether you choose to sit in the elegant indoor dining room, at the lively bar, or outside on the spacious terrace.
Recommended For: Couples seeking a romantic setting, sushi and steak lovers, weekend brunch enthusiasts, and diners looking for great wine and live music in a beautiful waterfront atmosphere.
- Start your meal with Three Beef Burger Sliders, topped with Vermont, American, or Blue cheese.
- Savor the superb Sesame Crusted Yellowfin Tuna served with stir-fried vegetables, sweet soy, and wasabi mayo.
- Enjoy the popular weekend brunch or visit during Monday’s excellent fixed-price three-course dinner special.
- Relax to the sounds of live music that enhance the friendly, lively vibe.
- Explore the award-winning wine cellar to perfectly complement your meal.
Mill Pond, 437 E Main St, Centerport, NY 11721, USA
Phone: 631-261-7663
Date Ideas:
3. Watch the Sunset with Your Toes in the Sand at Navy Beach
I love:
"Laid-back luxury meets Mediterranean-inspired seafood on the shores of Montauk."
Navy Beach in Montauk offers a one-of-a-kind beachfront dining experience where you can literally feel the sand between your toes as you enjoy your meal. For those who prefer to stay sand-free, the elegant indoor dining room features wall-to-wall windows, vintage bathing suit displays, and nostalgic photos of classic beach scenes.
Recommended For: Seafood enthusiasts, beach lovers, couples looking for a romantic sunset meal, and anyone who wants to sip cocktails with their feet in the sand.
- Begin your meal with a Maryland Jumbo Lump Crab Cake appetizer, packed with delicate flavors.
- Indulge in large plates like Fire Roasted Sea Scallops paired with chorizo, double smoked bacon, dates, and spiced piquillo tomato sauce.
- Choose your setting: toes-in-the-sand beach tables or the stylish dining room with vintage coastal décor.
- Enjoy a wide selection of beers and creative, imaginative cocktails to enhance your seaside experience.
- Soak in the unbeatable Montauk sunsets while savoring top-notch seafood and drinks.
Navy Beach, 16 Navy Rd, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: 631-668-6868
4. If You’re Craving Island Vibes in the Hamptons, Head to Nantucket’s
I enjoy:
"Tucked in Belle Terre, this cozy spot delivers lobster, steak, and a New England-inspired menu in a casual, upscale setting."
Nantucket's in downtown Port Jefferson is a charming seafood restaurant offering traditional American dishes and the freshest fish and seafood. With two cozy, inviting dining rooms perfect for private celebrations and a spacious outdoor patio shaded by large umbrellas, it’s a local favorite for relaxed and memorable meals.
Recommended For: Seafood lovers, families, groups celebrating special occasions, and anyone looking to enjoy outdoor patio dining with fresh local flavors.
- Savor the chef’s specialty seafood Bolognese, a unique and hearty standout dish.
- Choose from a diverse menu with options for every palate, from classic American fare to creative seafood plates.
- Relax on the large outdoor patio under shady umbrellas or book one of the intimate indoor dining rooms for private events.
- Sample handcrafted cocktails, fine wines, and craft beers from the full-service bar.
- Don’t miss their signature Lobster Bacon Bloody Mary for a fun and flavorful twist on a brunch favorite.
Nantucket's, 9 Trader’s Cove, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Phone: 631-509-4848
5. Savor Artful Bites and Stylish Ambiance at Tullulah’s
I like:
"Global small plates, inventive cocktails, and moody decor create an unforgettable dining experience."
Tullulah's is a newly renovated gem in Bay Shore, offering a delightful blend of charm, creativity, and surprise. Step inside the cozy bistro space with its sleek, inviting bar, and beyond the curtain, discover a spacious dining room with minimalist décor, plush leather banquettes, and a striking Alfred Eisenstaedt photograph.
Recommended For: Adventurous food lovers, couples seeking a chic date spot, fans of seasonal menus, and anyone who enjoys craft beers and old-fashioned cocktails in a stylish setting.
- Try the creative risotto with suckling pig confit, a signature surprise on the seasonal menu.
- Enjoy venison with black barley or duck with red beets, crafted from fresh, local ingredients.
- Relax in the elegant dining room behind the curtain, or sip at the sleek front bar with its vibrant atmosphere.
- Choose from a curated selection of craft beers and expertly made classic cocktails.
- Experience a culinary journey where each visit offers something new based on what’s in season.
Tullulah's, 12 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: 631-969-9800
6. Go Gourmet and Casual at LT Burger in Sag Harbor
I Recommend:
"Chef Laurent Tourondel’s take on burgers, shakes, and comfort food is both family-friendly and foodie-approved."
LT Burger Sag Harbor transforms classic American comfort food into a gourmet experience right in the heart of Sag Harbor. This is not just a meal — it’s a playful culinary celebration topped off with decadent shakes in flavors like French Toast or Death by Oreo.
Recommended For: Families looking for a fun meal, burger aficionados, couples on a casual date, and anyone craving elevated comfort food with a gourmet twist.
- Try the signature Angus beef burger or explore creative options like fresh fish or veggie patties with inventive toppings.
- Indulge in over-the-top shakes, including the unforgettable French Toast or Death by Oreo varieties.
- Relax in the lively atmosphere featuring quirky décor and a cozy fireplace that makes you feel right at home.
- Bring the kids for family-friendly fun, complete with coloring books and a special kids’ menu designed just for them.
- Experience how Chef Tourondel elevates the humble burger-and-fries combo into a standout Sag Harbor dining experience.
LT Burger Sag Harbor, 62 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone: 631-899-4646
I get asked this a lot so I decided to include it:
-
How far is Long Island from Manhattan?
- Long Island is just a short train ride from Manhattan, but it offers a completely different atmosphere, lifestyle, and restaurant scene.
-
What makes Long Island’s restaurant scene unique?
- Long Island is surrounded by the ocean and intersected by rivers, making it home to a diverse range of great restaurants.
-
What types of dining experiences are available on Long Island?
- The island offers both unassuming and luxurious restaurants, catering to a variety of tastes and preferences.
-
What kind of food is Long Island known for?
- Long Island is famous for its fresh seafood, fish, and seasonal local produce, as well as wines from local wineries.
Map:
How did I do?
Is the article too broad, too narrow, or just right ? Do you like the presentation of photos and text? Let me know in the comments! If you want to see more in this location, I can put it on my editorial calendar. I'm listening!
Plan Your Trip