Romantic restaurants in Lancaster pair rustic countryside charm with elevated dining: candlelit barns, garden views, and menus inspired by the seasons. It’s where I toast with local wine as twilight settles over the rolling hills of Amish country.
I’ve got duck breast with cherry glaze, a glass of Pennsylvania Pinot Noir, and the scent of wildflowers drifting through the open windows—right here in charming, pastoral Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Who knew the farmland could feel so quietly luxurious?
"Field views, flickering candles, and farm-fresh flavors? This is Lancaster’s romantic side—earthy, elegant, and full of heart."
This is Why I Keep Coming Back for More:
Unique Romantic Restaurants in Lancaster:
1. Dine with Purpose at John J. Jeffries
Situated in a rural region of Pennsylvania, Lancaster County has ample farms in the area. John J. Jeffries serves dishes comprised of locally-sourced organic meats and vegetables from Central Pennsylvania. During a romantic evening, diners can indulge the senses with fresh, seasonal foods plated beautifully. The bar hosts a daily happy hour. Small plates include tasty delights like hickory smoked trout caesar salad or crispy pork belly with mac and cheese. Hungry diners can feast on grass-fed beef meatballs with mac and cheese or Keiser Farm turkey. OpenTable awarded the restaurant the Diners’ Choice.
300 Harrisburg Avenue, Lancaster, PA, Phone: 717-431-3307
2. Feast in Rustic Luxury at The Log Cabin
Couples looking for an evening of fine dining can treat themselves at The Log Cabin. Flat wooden beams create a rustic, natural ambiance. First built in 1929, the restaurant consists of oak logs taken from the Lehoy Forest, a region formerly inhabited by the Nanticoke Indians. During the Prohibition Era, the historic building served as a speakeasy. Today, Chef Steven Painter creates an exquisite menu. The raw bar features east coast and west coast oysters plus king crab legs. Couples can feast on aged beef or house specialties like duck a l’orange. The kitchen also cooks seafood dishes like crab cakes or smoked bacon crusted cod.
11 Lehoy Forest Drive, Leola, PA, Phone: 717-626-9999
3. Savor Timeless Elegance at Arthur’s Terrace Restaurant
Out in the countryside, couples can enjoy a romantic meal at Arthur's Terrace Restaurant. Floral arrangements create the feeling of sitting in a garden with views through the large windows to Lancaster’s gorgeous greenery. The decadent dinner buffet lets guests indulge in all-you-can-eat carved prime rib, seafood, chicken, crab bisque, a salad bar, and desserts. During the daytime, guests can also sample the bountiful breakfast or lunch buffets or order from the selection of a-la-carte menu items served throughout the day. As a part of the Eden Resort and Suites, Arthur’s invites guests of the hotel or visitors in Lancaster.
222 Eden Road, Lancaster, PA, Phone: 717-569-6444
4. Treat Your Taste Buds at Bistro Barberet & Bakery
While enjoying the bucolic landscape of the Lancaster area, visitors can sample French cuisine at Bistro Barberet & Bakery. The restaurant’s owner and operator, Chef Cedric Barberet, has over 25 years of experience cooking classic French food along with a Master’s Degree in Pastry from Patisserie Chereau in France. His background includes working as Executive Pastry Chef at Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Club in Palm Beach, Florida. At the Bistro Barberet, guests can feast on everyday dishes like quiche lorraine and croque monsieur to delicacies like foie gras and tartare. The bakery opens for breakfast, and diners can also come in for lunch, dinner, or Sunday brunch.
26 East King Street, Lancaster, PA, Phone: 717-690-2354, See the Map
Lancaster is 1 hr 45 min (81.3 miles via US-1 S) from Philadelphia.
Top attractions include: Dutch Wonderland, The Phillips Museum of Art, Amish Farm and House, and the North Museum of Nature and Science.
Date Ideas:
5. Go Global with Grace at Citronnelle
Although Lancaster sits in a rural region of Pennsylvania, couples in town looking for a romantic meal while enjoying classic French cuisine can find it at Citronnelle. The restaurant considers the many cultural influences found in France, as evidenced by its unique, international menu. Situated in downtown Lancaster, Citronnelle focuses on cooking styles from France but also infuses cuisine from Asia and Africa. During Global Nights, diners can tour the world through their taste buds. Specialty menus highlight recipes from different countries, whether Egypt in the Middle East or Ecuador in Latin America. This BYOB emphasizes using locally-sourced, fresh meats and produce.
110 West Orange Street, Lancaster, PA, Phone: 717-208-6697
6. Unwind Where History Meets Flavor at Cork & Cap Restaurant
Guests in town looking to experience a piece of American history should visit the Cork & Cap Restaurant. The eatery sits in the former Armstrong Cork and Kerr Glass Company, a factory built in 1865. If only those walls could talk! During lunch, dinner, or brunch, diners can admire the edifice and imagine the people who once worked there. The menu boasts plenty of American classics like lobster rolls, crab cakes, and burgers. Every Wednesday, Cork & Cap hosts a Prime Rib Night with specials on cuts. Sundays nights mean seafood, with a combination of lobster tail, snow crab legs, and sea scallops.
480 New Holland Avenue Suite 3000, Lancaster, PA, Phone: 717-735-2025
Plan Your Trip