The Hamptons have long been synonymous with romance and coastal refinement—where windswept beaches, historic charm, and farm-to-table dining come together in perfect harmony. Whether you're drawn to Montauk's rugged beauty, East Hampton's galleries, or Sag Harbor's storybook streets, there's a stay that captures the heart of it all.
Best Places to Stay in The Hamptons, NY
Gurney’s Montauk Resort
Gurney’s Montauk Resort in Montauk felt like the Hamptons turned oceanfront spa haven—salt air, sunlit lounges, and the sound of surf meeting sand. I remember standing barefoot on the deck at sunrise, coffee in hand, thinking, "This is the reset I didn’t know I needed."
What I Loved Most: The ocean-fed seawater pool and full-service spa—relaxation elevated to ritual. I enjoyed biking to Montauk Point Light which took about 30 minutes from the resort.
My highlight? Dinner at Scarpetta Beach: buttery lobster tagliolini with a glass of Vermentino, the waves practically clapping in approval.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Luxurious, coastal, wellness-centered
- Highlights: Private beach, spa, seawater pool, on-site dining
- Best For: Couples in need of true rest, spa lovers, ocean seekers
- Address: Gurney’s Montauk Resort, 290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
Baron’s Cove Hotel, Sag Harbor
Baron’s Cove Hotel felt like a retro-glam harbor escape—American flags waving, Adirondack chairs facing the bay, and a soft breeze of nostalgia. I remember rocking on the porch at golden hour, thinking, "This is how summer was meant to feel."
What I Loved Most: The saltwater pool with striped umbrellas and harbor views—pure storybook charm.
My highlight? A candlelit dinner of local scallops and truffle mashed potatoes at the cozy tavern downstairs.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Nautical, polished, Americana chic
- Highlights: Harbor views, pool, bicycles, year-round dining
- Best For: Classic couples’ retreats, stylish weekends, Sag Harbor dreamers
- Address: Baron’s Cove Hotel, 31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY
Address: Baron’s Cove Hotel, 31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, Phone: 844-227-6672
The Maidstone, East Hampton
The Maidstone in East Hampton felt like sleeping in a gallery—Scandinavian flair, bold art, and that deliciously eccentric East Hampton calm. I remember sinking into a velvet chair beside a roaring fire, thinking, "This is creativity you can live inside."
What I Loved Most: The design-forward rooms, each one themed around cultural icons—surprising and cozy.
My highlight? Brunch at the on-site café: smoked salmon tartine with pickled onions and a beet mimosa.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Eclectic, artsy, intellectual
- Highlights: Curated art, unique rooms, pet-friendly, intimate setting
- Best For: Artists, writers, creative couples
- Address: The Maidstone, 207 Main St, East Hampton, NY
Address:
The Maidstone, 207 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937Phone: 631-324-5006
The 1770 House, East Hampton
The 1770 House felt like a candlelit step back in time—original beams, hushed hallways, and whispers of colonial romance. I remember descending into the Tavern and feeling wrapped in centuries of quiet conversation, thinking, "Some places speak softly and still say everything."
What I Loved Most: The intimacy—only six guest rooms, each more charming than the next.
My highlight? Roasted duck breast with fig reduction and rosemary potatoes in the cozy underground tavern.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Historic, elegant, timeless
- Highlights: Fine dining, intimate rooms, candlelit tavern, central location
- Best For: Old souls, anniversaries, literary weekends
- Address: The 1770 House, 143 Main St, East Hampton, NY
Address:
The 1770 House, 143 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937Phone: 631-324-1770
Arbor View House, North Fork
Arbor View House felt like the home of a dear friend—welcoming, fragrant with lavender, and full of soulful conversation. I remember the scent of fresh scones wafting up the stairs, thinking, "We’re not just guests—we’re being cared for."
What I Loved Most: The candlelit whirlpool baths and the curated wine tasting afternoons—it felt healing.
My highlight? A multi-course homemade breakfast: crème brûlée French toast, local berries, and fresh mint tea from the garden.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Romantic B&B, soulful, rejuvenating
- Highlights: Gourmet breakfasts, spa tubs, wine tastings, personal hosts
- Best For: Romantic getaways, wellness seekers, couples who love connection
- Address: Arbor View House, 8900 Main Rd, East Marion, NY
Address:
Arbor View House, 8900 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939Phone: 631-477-8440
The Quogue Club at Hallock House
The Quogue Club at Hallock House felt like a polished coastal retreat—buttoned-up, yet breezy in the best way. I remember sipping a martini on the wraparound porch, thinking, "This is Hamptons elegance with all the warmth of a true inn."
What I Loved Most: The soft linens, curated artwork, and sense of belonging that lingered from check-in to farewell.
My highlight? Dinner in the dining room: seared scallops with roasted parsnips and citrus beurre blanc—refined, seasonal, unforgettable.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Sophisticated, discreet, gracious
- Highlights: Elegant dining, library lounge, complimentary beach passes, fitness center
- Best For: Refined travelers, small celebrations, long weekend escapes
- Address: The Quogue Club at Hallock House, 47 Quogue St, Quogue, NY
Address:
The Quogue Club at Hallock House, 47 Quogue Street, Quogue, NY 11959Phone: 631-653-0100
Capri Hotel, Southampton
Capri Hotel in Southampton felt like a sun-soaked summer fling—fashionable, fast-paced, and full of energy. I remember lounging poolside with a spritz in hand, thinking, "This is where New York unwinds and lets loose."
What I Loved Most: The retro-modern vibe and DJ beats pulsing from the outdoor bar—glamour without the stuffiness.
My highlight? Grilled octopus and watermelon salad at the on-site restaurant, followed by late-night cocktails and laughter under the stars.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Trendy, youthful, high-energy
- Highlights: Pool lounge, summer events, bar & restaurant, stylish rooms
- Best For: Social weekends, bachelorette escapes, style-savvy couples
- Address: Capri Hotel, 281 County Rd 39A, Southampton, NY
Address:
Capri Hotel, 281 County Rd 39A, Southampton, NY 11968Phone: 631-504-6575
East Hampton Art House
East Hampton Art House felt like a creative retreat wrapped in luxury—gallery walls, curated gardens, and a hum of inspiration in every corner. I remember sketching on the patio as golden hour arrived, thinking, "I could stay in this light forever."
What I Loved Most: The fine art everywhere—from the hallways to the bathrooms—it didn’t just decorate, it whispered stories.
My highlight? A breakfast spread of lemon-zest waffles, ricotta, and handmade fig preserves, served beside the koi pond.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Artistic, serene, luxurious B&B
- Highlights: Personal art collection, heated pool, gourmet breakfast, garden studio
- Best For: Creative souls, serene escapes, romantic rejuvenation
- Address: East Hampton Art House, 9 Bon Pinck Way, East Hampton, NY
Address:
East Hampton Art House, 9 Bon Pinck Way, East Hampton, NY 11937Phone: 631-907-4645
Conclusion
From oceanfront resorts with luxurious spas to charming inns tucked behind garden hedges, The Hamptons offer something special for every couple seeking romance and rest. And your stay is just the beginning.
Pair your trip with local adventures by exploring the best things to do on Long Island, planning a scenic day trip, or sinking your toes into the finest beaches on Long Island. Looking to add something different? Try a night under the stars with a guide to camping on Long Island or discover small-town charm in places like Commack.
No matter your style, The Hamptons are waiting—with sunrise swims, twilight cocktails, and memories you’ll carry long after the sand has washed away.