Mama Carolla's | Unique Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis
© Mama Carolla's
  • Please support our journalism through affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure
  • Written by our human editors, structured with the help of AI.

Review & FAQ:

Mama Carolla's was established at a time when restaurants were tables placed around the home for visitors to get a decent home cooked meal. With the aim of cooking for her customers just as she would cook for her family, the owner reopened the restaurant in 1997. Since then, the restaurant has been awarded one of the Top 50 Most Romantic Restaurants by USA Today. Antipasti favorites include the Portobello mushrooms stuffed with crab meat and cheese, fried ravioli, and bruschetta topped with freshly smoked mozzarella. Entrees such as clam linguine, Mediterranean rigatoni, and sautéed chicken and shrimp penne pasta have become local favorites.

Mama Carolla's, 1031 E 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220, Phone: 317-259-9412

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Ambrosia Brozinni Pizzeria Capri Restaurant Iaria's Italian Restaurant Iozzo's Garden of Italy Mama Carolla's Napolese Nicolino's Italian Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta Sangiovese Ristorante Some Guys Vito Provolone's Bazbeaux Pizza Enzo’s Pizza Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza

Explore more: Indianapolis, Indiana > Unique Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis

Plan Your Trip

Get Ready to Go!

Need some more help?


Go to travel reservations.