A stone’s throw from the famous Crescent Beach on Shelter Island New York, Shelter Island House is a beautiful, beach-inspired boutique hotel ideally located for exploring the little island.

The hotel boasts eight beautifully appointed and luxuriously furnished suites, with spacious en-suite bathrooms, whirlpool tubs and large windows that let natural light stream in and offer stunning views over the gardens and swimming pool.

A romantic Victorian gazebo is perfect for al fresco dining under the stars, while newly restored pétanque courts offer a relaxing way to spend the afternoon. The hotel offers free use of bicycles, newspapers and board games. An old-fashioned covered porch with comfortable wooden rockers and wicker furniture beckons for lazy days with a book.

Refill your joie de vivre meter with a brunch of homemade pastries, cocktails on the wraparound porch, a leisurely bike ride to the beach, or an indulgent soak in your suite’s oversized tub at this delightful beach retreat.

Plan Your Trip

Get Ready to Go!

Need some more help?


Read our Reservations & Travel Planning Tips guide.