"Plan a weekend trip to Long Island and experience this charming coastal escape. This unique bed and breakfast is relaxing and luxurious. "

Review:★★★★★ Originally established in the 1800s, this beautifully restored boutique hotel has gracious accommodations and modern amenities. I loved beoing within walking distance of lovely beaches and Mashomack Preserve.

Recommended for

Romantic Getaways: Enjoy spa bathrooms, cozy evenings by the pool, and intimate island dining.

Outdoor Enthusiasts: Walk to the beach, bike the island, or explore over 2,000 acres of nearby nature preserve.

Families & Groups: Spacious multi-room suites and a friendly atmosphere make it ideal for reunions and special occasions.

Foodies: Savor locally inspired cuisine, signature cocktails, and daily breakfast on the sunny deck.

What to Expect

  • Gracious Accommodations: Stylish guest rooms and suites with spa-like bathrooms, premium linens, and curated art.
  • Exceptional Amenities: Seasonal outdoor pool, petanque courts, bicycles, and daily continental breakfast.
  • On-Site Dining: A contemporary tavern serving New American cuisine and a casual poolside bar with light fare.
  • Prime Location: Steps from beaches and minutes from the Mashomack Nature Preserve’s scenic trails and wildlife.

Guest Accommodations

  • Queen Rooms: 250 sq. ft. on the first or second floors, with garden views and private spa bathrooms.
  • Double Queen Rooms: 450 sq. ft. rooms with two queen beds, ideal for families or friends, offering views of the garden and pool.
  • Deluxe King Rooms: 270 sq. ft. with plush king beds and elegant spa bathrooms on the first or second floor.
  • King Suites: 450 sq. ft. suites with additional seating areas and sleeper sofas for extra guests.
  • The Osprey Suite: A luxurious three-bedroom, two-bath suite with full kitchen, living room, and accommodations for up to eight guests.

In-Room Features

  • Flat-screen TVs with cable and surround sound systems
  • Private spa bathrooms with walk-in showers, spa baths, thick robes, and deluxe toiletries
  • In-room snacks and beverages
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi throughout the property
  • Original artwork and chic, contemporary furnishings

Dining & Drinks

  • The Tavern Restaurant: Serves seasonally driven New American fare made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
  • Signature Beverages: Enjoy expertly crafted cocktails, global wines, and regional craft beers.
  • Poolside Bar: Offers light meals, salads, snacks, and refreshing drinks beside the pool deck.
  • Breakfast: Complimentary continental breakfast served daily on the sunny deck.

Resort Amenities

  • Seasonal outdoor swimming pool with loungers and umbrellas
  • Petanque courts, lit for nighttime play
  • Complimentary bicycles for island exploration
  • Beach gear: umbrellas, chairs, and towels
  • Gift shop offering local souvenirs, home décor, and clothing

Location Highlights

  • Walking distance to Shelter Island’s beautiful beaches
  • Moments from Mashomack Nature Preserve—a 2,000-acre haven of woodlands, wetlands, and trails

Contact & Booking

  • Address: 11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
  • Hotel Phone: 631-749-1633
  • The Tavern Phone: 631-749-5659
  • Website: shelterislandhouse.com

Map:


Plan Your Trip