Blending historic charm, coastal elegance, and warm island hospitality, Shelter Island House offers an unforgettable bed and breakfast experience in the heart of Long Island. Originally established in the 1800s, this beautifully restored boutique hotel delights guests with gracious accommodations, elevated cuisine, and modern amenities—all within walking distance of pristine beaches and the expansive Mashomack Preserve.

Recommended For

Romantic Getaways: Enjoy spa bathrooms, cozy evenings by the pool, and intimate island dining.

Outdoor Enthusiasts: Walk to the beach, bike the island, or explore over 2,000 acres of nearby nature preserve.

Families & Groups: Spacious multi-room suites and a friendly atmosphere make it ideal for reunions and special occasions.

Foodies: Savor locally inspired cuisine, signature cocktails, and daily breakfast on the sunny deck.

What to Expect

  • Gracious Accommodations: Stylish guest rooms and suites with spa-like bathrooms, premium linens, and curated art.
  • Exceptional Amenities: Seasonal outdoor pool, petanque courts, bicycles, and daily continental breakfast.
  • On-Site Dining: A contemporary tavern serving New American cuisine and a casual poolside bar with light fare.
  • Prime Location: Steps from beaches and minutes from the Mashomack Nature Preserve’s scenic trails and wildlife.

Guest Accommodations

  • Queen Rooms: 250 sq. ft. on the first or second floors, with garden views and private spa bathrooms.
  • Double Queen Rooms: 450 sq. ft. rooms with two queen beds, ideal for families or friends, offering views of the garden and pool.
  • Deluxe King Rooms: 270 sq. ft. with plush king beds and elegant spa bathrooms on the first or second floor.
  • King Suites: 450 sq. ft. suites with additional seating areas and sleeper sofas for extra guests.
  • The Osprey Suite: A luxurious three-bedroom, two-bath suite with full kitchen, living room, and accommodations for up to eight guests.

In-Room Features

  • Flat-screen TVs with cable and surround sound systems
  • Private spa bathrooms with walk-in showers, spa baths, thick robes, and deluxe toiletries
  • In-room snacks and beverages
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi throughout the property
  • Original artwork and chic, contemporary furnishings

Dining & Drinks

  • The Tavern Restaurant: Serves seasonally driven New American fare made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
  • Signature Beverages: Enjoy expertly crafted cocktails, global wines, and regional craft beers.
  • Poolside Bar: Offers light meals, salads, snacks, and refreshing drinks beside the pool deck.
  • Breakfast: Complimentary continental breakfast served daily on the sunny deck.

Resort Amenities

  • Seasonal outdoor swimming pool with loungers and umbrellas
  • Petanque courts, lit for nighttime play
  • Complimentary bicycles for island exploration
  • Beach gear: umbrellas, chairs, and towels
  • Gift shop offering local souvenirs, home décor, and clothing

Location Highlights

  • Walking distance to Shelter Island’s beautiful beaches
  • Moments from Mashomack Nature Preserve—a 2,000-acre haven of woodlands, wetlands, and trails

Contact & Booking

  • Address: 11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
  • Hotel Phone: 631-749-1633
  • The Tavern Phone: 631-749-5659
  • Website: shelterislandhouse.com

Map:


Plan Your Trip