Blending sophisticated style, historic elegance, and warm hospitality, Shelter Island House has been offering guests a unique bed and breakfast experience on Long Island for years. Established in the 1800s, the beautifully refurbished guesthouse boasts inspiring architecture, luxurious accommodations, exceptional amenities, and a warm and welcoming ambiance.
- Luxurious Accommodations:
- Graciously sized rooms featuring chic décor and local artworks.
- Private spa bathrooms designed for relaxation.
- Modern amenities include complimentary wireless Internet.
- Exceptional Amenities:
- On-site restaurant, bar, and bakery offering delightful culinary options.
- Outdoor swimming pool for leisure and relaxation.
- Bicycle rentals available for exploring the beautiful island.
- Complimentary breakfast served daily on the sunny deck.
- Evening drinks by the pool accompanied by a game of petanque.
- Prime Location:
- Walking distance to one of Long Island's most picturesque beaches.
- Close proximity to the Mashomack Nature Preserve, offering over 2,000 acres of pristine wilderness and wildlife to explore.
Guest Accommodations
- Guest Accommodations:
- Shelter Island House offers beautifully appointed, individually decorated guest rooms and suites.
- Features include:
- Contemporary, chic décor with original artworks
- Private spa bathrooms with walk-in showers, spa baths, fresh towels, thick bathrobes, and deluxe bath products
- Flat-screen televisions with cable channels and surround sound systems
- In-room snacks and drinks
- Complimentary wireless Internet
- Rooms are located on the first and second floors, offering beautiful garden views.
- Queen Rooms:
- 250 square feet in size, located on the first and second floors.
Dining
The Tavern Restaurant is situated at Shelter Island House and serves a range of New American-style Seasonally driven menus filled with innovative dishes prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, accompanied by a selection of signature cocktails, craft beers and fine wines from around the world.
A casual poolside bar offers a small menu of light meals, snacks, salads and drinks, which can be enjoyed on the pool deck next to the swimming pool.
Plan this Vacation
Amenities at the Shelter Island House include a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a poolside bar with a Grab n’ Go menu, an on-site tavern that serves New American Cuisine and outdoor petanque courts, which can be lit for nighttime play. There are complimentary bicycles for exploring the island, beach umbrellas, chairs and towels to use on the beach, and free wireless Internet throughout the property. A gift shop sells an array of souvenirs, clothing, home décor and other memorabilia.
11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, Phone: 631-749-1633 (Hotel) Phone: 631-749-5659 (The Tavern)
- Please support our journalism through the following affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure.
Plan Your Trip
Get Ready to Go!
- Search flights and stays nearby.
- Book your car rental.
Need some more help?
Read our Reservations & Travel Planning Tips guide.