Martha's Vineyard Restaurants

Alchemy Bistro and Bar is an upscale dining destination in Edgartown known for its refined seafood and meat dishes, artisan cocktails, and elegant ambiance. The bistro blends local ingredients with international culinary influences to craft unforgettable meals served seven nights a week.

Recommended For: Upscale date nights, seafood lovers, and guests seeking sophisticated island cuisine with a contemporary twist.

• Feast on standout entrées like sake-marinated black cod, cornmeal-crusted Ipswich belly clams, and Spanish octopus and tuna salad.
• Indulge in decadent desserts such as figgy toffee pudding or yuzu and pomegranate crème brûlée.
• Sip on artfully crafted specialty cocktails from a creative drink menu.
• Reserve a table easily online or by phone to secure a spot at this in-demand Martha’s Vineyard gem.

Alchemy Bistro and Bar, 71 Main Street, Edgartown, MA 02557
Phone: 508-627-9999

Behind the Bookstore is a charming hidden gem tucked behind Edgartown Books, offering a cozy atmosphere with gourmet coffee, inventive meals, and a welcoming vibe all day long. It’s a favorite for both locals and visitors seeking delicious food and crafted drinks in a quiet garden setting.

Recommended For: Coffee lovers, brunch enthusiasts, and anyone looking for a quiet outdoor café with a creative culinary twist.

• Enjoy morning favorites like grilled eggs, granola bowls, and avocado toast with ricotta and salmon.
• Choose from a range of salads, sandwiches, and international dishes like Peruvian ceviche and shiitake specialties for lunch and dinner.
• Unwind at the full-service bar with handcrafted cocktails infused with fresh herbs, fruits, and vegetables.
• Relax in the shaded garden seating for a peaceful café experience.

Behind the Bookstore, 46 Main Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: 774-549-9123

Date Ideas:

The Port Hunter is a lively and trendy Edgartown hotspot, known for its inventive seafood and meat dishes, vibrant cocktail menu, and energetic live music scene. Located on Main Street, it’s a go-to destination for great food and nightlife wrapped into one dynamic experience.

Recommended For: Foodies looking for fresh, creative cuisine and travelers seeking a fun night out with live music and cocktails.

• Indulge in standouts like avocado toast with jicama and feta, Buffalo Brussels sprouts, and grilled clams with leeks.
• Savor hearty entrees such as hanger steak with caramelized onions.
• Pair your meal with craft cocktails and specialty drinks from their acclaimed bar.
• Enjoy the vibrant ambiance with live music from local and touring artists.

The Port Hunter, 55 Main Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: 508-627-7747

Atria is a stylish and versatile dining destination in Edgartown that combines elegance with casual comfort through its unique indoor-outdoor setting. The restaurant is split into refined and relaxed dining spaces, making it suitable for a romantic night out, a casual bite, or a lively gathering.

Recommended For: Diners looking for both fine dining and a relaxed bar scene, as well as anyone planning private events like weddings or corporate functions.

• Dine on expertly crafted seafood dishes, Mexican-inspired cuisine, and fresh soups and salads in the main restaurant.
• Unwind at the Brick Cellar Bar, a celebrity-favorite serving up gourmet burgers and Asian and Mediterranean-inspired plates.
• Sip on a curated selection of craft cocktails, fine wines, and premium spirits.
• Host your next wedding, business event, or celebration with their professional catering and rental services.

Atria, 137 Main Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: 508-627-5850

Chesca's Restaurant offers refined comfort food in a welcoming atmosphere, ideal for a relaxed evening out or a romantic dinner. With a charming bar, lounge, and patio overlooking downtown Edgartown, guests can enjoy hearty dishes and fine wines while taking in scenic views.

Recommended For: Diners seeking a blend of gourmet and classic fare, patio dining, and indulgent desserts in Edgartown.

• Enjoy house specialties like grilled salmon, braised beef short ribs, lobster ravioli, and chicken marsala.
• Savor pasta dishes including angel hair with white clam sauce and simple bento box offerings for lighter meals.
• Treat yourself to house-made desserts such as Chef David's crème caramel, Key lime pie, and the signature Snowball (vanilla ice cream with sponge cake and chocolate crumbles).
• Relax with a drink on the patio, in the lounge, or at the full-service bar.

Chesca's Restaurant, 38 N Water Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: 508-627-1234

Espresso Love is a quirky, award-winning coffee shop on Martha’s Vineyard, celebrated for its laidback vibe, hearty sandwiches, fresh salads, burgers, and delicious quiche. Voted Best of the Vineyard in 2016, this café serves up healthy, flavorful dishes alongside fresh-brewed coffee, attracting both locals and visitors alike.

Recommended For: Coffee lovers, casual diners, breakfast fans, and anyone looking for a cozy, delicious café experience.

• Savor freshly brewed coffee paired with sandwiches, soups, and salads.
• Indulge in quiche, burgers, and daily specials at wallet-friendly prices.
• Relax in a charming, laidback space perfect for lingering over a cup.
• Enjoy catering options for breakfast, lunch, or dinner for large groups.
• Visit a beloved local favorite with locations in Boston and Martha’s Vineyard.

Espresso Love, 17 Church Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: 508-627-9211

Larsen's Fish Market is a beloved Menemsha institution, offering freshly caught Atlantic Ocean fish and seafood since 1969. Founded by Mary and Louis Larsen to support the local fishing community, this charming market draws visitors eager to savor striped bass, cod, bluefish, swordfish, lobster, oysters, and more, all served with authentic coastal charm.

Recommended For: Seafood lovers, families, and anyone seeking fresh-off-the-boat catches and a true Martha’s Vineyard experience.

• Choose from daily fresh fish selections like striped bass, cod, and swordfish.
• Feast on lobster, oysters, shrimp, scallops, calamari, and other local delights.
• Shop for Larsen’s branded t-shirts, hoodies, caps, mugs, and more.
• Experience the charm of a historic fish market rooted in community tradition.
• Enjoy a taste of Menemsha’s vibrant fishing culture, straight from the docks.

Larsen's Fish Market, 56 Basin Road, Chilmark, MA 02535
Phone: 508-645-2680