Nantucket, with its cobblestone streets, historic charm, and windswept beaches, offers an idyllic setting for a romantic getaway. Whether you're strolling through the quaint town, savoring fresh seafood, or watching the sunset over the ocean, the island provides countless moments to cherish. To help you plan your perfect escape, here are the most enchanting accommodations that blend comfort, character, and intimacy.
Best Romantic Places to Stay on Nantucket
For Couples: The White Elephant Hotel
The White Elephant Hotel felt like stepping into a Nantucket daydream...crisp linens, harbor breeze, and a calm that whispered luxury. I remember sitting on our balcony, sailboats gliding by, thinking, "This is the rhythm I didn’t know I needed."
What I Loved Most: The waterfront lawn with plush loungers and quiet views of the harbor.
My highlight? Dinner at Brant Point Grill: buttery lobster with sweet corn risotto and a glass of rosé. It was summer elegance on a fork.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Upscale coastal charm, serene harbor views
- Highlights: Waterfront suites, spa, afternoon port and cheese, complimentary bikes
- Best For: Anniversaries, luxury escapes, proposal weekends
- Address: 50 Easton St, Nantucket, MA
Address:
50 Easton Street, Nantucket, MA 02584Phone: 508-228-2500
For Boutique Fans: 76 Main
76 Main felt like a stylish secret tucked just off the cobblestones—historic yet fresh, cozy but with a cool confidence. I remember curling up by the fire pit with a blanket and a cocktail, thinking, "We could stay right here all weekend."
What I Loved Most: The courtyard with glowing lanterns and intimate seating—it felt like a private garden party.
My highlight? Morning coffee and warm scones in the sun-dappled lounge, followed by lemon-ricotta pancakes at Black-Eyed Susan's.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Hip, intimate, boutique comfort
- Highlights: Fire pit courtyard, designer interiors, daily breakfast, BYOB cocktail mixer bar
- Best For: Stylish couples, weekenders, design lovers
- Address: 76 Main St, Nantucket, MA
Address:
76 Main Street, Nantucket, MA 02554Phone: 508-228-2533
For a Quiet Getaway: Seven Sea Street Inn
Seven Sea Street Inn felt like coming home to a dream you once had—hydrangeas in bloom, candlelit breakfasts, and a porch that hummed with peace. I remember watching the sky change colors from the cupola, thinking, "If quiet could be bottled, it would feel like this."
What I Loved Most: The cozy intimacy and heartfelt hospitality—it felt like we were part of the island’s fabric.
My highlight? Homemade quiche with chives and sharp cheddar, served with fresh berries and local jam in the sunny breakfast room.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Quaint, warm, quietly elegant
- Highlights: Rooftop cupola views, gourmet breakfast, fire-lit parlor
- Best For: Elopements, peaceful retreats, introvert getaways
- Address: 7 Sea St, Nantucket, MA
Address:
7 Sea Street, Nantucket, MA 02554Phone: 508-228-3577
For a quiet more personal experience: The Carlisle House Inn, Nantucket, MA
The Carlisle House Inn felt like stepping through a portal to the 1700s—creaking floors, antique four-poster beds, and a hush that settled the soul. I remember reading on the porch swing as a breeze drifted through, thinking, "Some places hold time differently."
What I Loved Most: The historic character paired with gentle comforts—each room told a story.
My highlight? Breakfast in the garden: cranberry scones, sharp cheddar omelet, and strong coffee in a blue-and-white teacup.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Historic, romantic, whisper-quiet
- Highlights: Period furniture, porch swing, central location, intimate feel
- Best For: History lovers, quiet couples, vintage romantics
- Address: 26 N Water St, Nantucket, MA
Address:
26 N Water Street, Nantucket, MA 02554Phone: 508-228-0720
For Personal Service: Union Street Inn
Union Street Inn felt like staying in the pages of a well-designed novel—polished antiques, coastal pastels, and that quiet kind of luxury you feel in your bones. I remember sinking into the window seat, soft light spilling across my book, thinking, "This is what it means to exhale."
What I Loved Most: The blend of editorial design and homey warmth—it never felt overdone.
My highlight? Breakfast in the garden: brioche French toast with berries and maple syrup, served on white china under flowering vines.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Elegant, refined, intimate B&B charm
- Highlights: Gourmet breakfasts, curated interiors, garden patio, designer touches
- Best For: Aesthetes, quiet romantics, anniversary escapes
- Address: 7 Union St, Nantucket, MA
Address:
7 Union Street, Nantucket, MA 02554Phone: 508-228-9222
Relaxing Nantucket Hotels:
For a relaxed atmosphere: Brass Lantern Inn
Brass Lantern Inn felt like a warm hug wrapped in Nantucket sunshine—flowering window boxes, cheerful rooms, and a kindness that radiated from the staff. I remember the quiet joy of sipping tea in the side garden, thinking, "We’ve found the softest place to land."
What I Loved Most: The light-filled sitting room and the scent of lavender drifting from the pillows.
My highlight? Afternoon tea with lemon pound cake and strawberry jam, followed by a twilight stroll to the lighthouse.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Cozy, cheerful, thoughtfully welcoming
- Highlights: Garden seating, afternoon treats, pet-friendly rooms, fireplace lounge
- Best For: Couples with dogs, peaceful weekenders, lighthearted escapes
- Address: 11 N Water St, Nantucket, MA
Address:
11 N Water Street, Nantucket, MA 02554Phone: 508-228-4064
For a stylish stay: Life House
Life House felt like a reimagined whaling captain’s home—but through the lens of a minimalist poet. Clean lines, botanical stillness, and storytelling in every room. I remember the scent of sea salt and sage as we walked in, thinking, "This is where modern and memory meet."
What I Loved Most: The parlor’s moody, library-like calm—just us, a record player, and the hush of dusk.
My highlight? Oysters and a citrus salad at The Tap Room, followed by espresso martinis at dusk in the courtyard.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Modern vintage, moody, literary-chic
- Highlights: Design-forward spaces, vintage books, plant-filled nooks, intimate bar
- Best For: Creative couples, design lovers, nostalgic minimalists
- Address: 10 Cliff Rd, Nantucket, MA
Address:
Life House, 10 Cliff Road, Nantucket, MA 02554Phone: 508-228-0530
For budget-conscious travelers: The Nantucket Inn
The Nantucket Inn felt like a playful breath of fresh air—spacious, easygoing, and unpretentious in the best way. I remember watching planes glide in as we clinked coffee mugs on the deck, thinking, "What a joy to slow down without fuss."
What I Loved Most: The relaxed atmosphere and lush lawn, perfect for picnics and barefoot mornings.
My highlight? Clam chowder and a lobster roll at The Downeyflake, followed by blueberry pie and laughter in our room.
Plan your trip:
- Vibe: Relaxed, classic, value-friendly
- Highlights: Outdoor pool, shuttle service, tennis courts, hearty breakfast buffet
- Best For: Casual couples, budget-conscious romantics, last-minute getaways
- Address: 1 Miller Ln, Nantucket, MA
Address:
One Miller Lane, Nantucket Island, MA 02554Phone: 800-321-8484
Conclusion
From luxurious waterfront hotels to cozy inns nestled in the heart of town, Nantucket's diverse lodging options cater to every couple's dream retreat.
Beyond your accommodations, the island beckons with activities and sights to enhance your romantic experience. Discover the best things to do on Nantucket, explore its pristine beaches, and consider other charming Nantucket hotels for your stay.
For broader coastal adventures, check out the best beaches in New England. Let Nantucket's timeless allure create unforgettable memories for you and your loved one.