- Please support our journalism through affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure
Review:
Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant brings the taste of the old country to the Midwest. This highly rated eatery serves up traditional Mediterranean cuisine. The charming restaurant, reminiscent of an Italian villa, conjures up images of Tuscany, although the founder, Mama Corolla, comes from Omaha, Nebraska, herself. Mama brought her dream to life of revisiting her roots at the Old Italian Restaurant. Mama keeps a house wine list in half carafes, carafes, and bottles. Diners can delight in all kinds of pasta, meat, and seafood plates as well as Mama’s speciality dishes. USA Today Travel has listed Mama Carolla’s in its 10 Best Restaurants Indianapolis.
Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant, 1031 East 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN, Phone: 317-259-9412
Plan Your Trip
Get Ready to Go!
- Search flights and stays nearby.
- Book your tour or local activity.
- Book your car rental.
Need some more help?
Read our Reservations & Travel Planning Tips guide.