- Please support our journalism through affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure
Another lovely location in Long Island for apple picking and other fun fall activities, The Milk Pail is owned by the Halsey family, who have literally been farming and living off the land for over three centuries! The Milk Pail itself has been running since 1969 and was originally named for the milk that was sold there, but has grown into one of Long Island's top apple orchards in the years that followed.
The Milk Pail, 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976, Phone: 631-537-2565
Plan Your Trip
Get Ready to Go!
- Search flights and stays nearby.
- Book your tour or local activity.
- Book your car rental.
Need some more help?
Go to travel reservations.