• Please support our journalism through affiliate links. Affiliate Disclosure
  • Written by our human editors, structured with the help of AI.

Review & FAQ:

For visitors on the hunt for a quiet, secluded, and beautiful beach getaway, look no further than Water Island. Contrary to what its name suggests, Water Island is in fact not an island. Rather, it is a private community on Fire Island Beach and is composed of roughly 50 houses. As it is surrounded by several beaches and parks, Water Island is perfect for the introverted traveler or someone who simply wants to get away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. As Water Island is a private community, the only way to experience it is to rent a beach home in the area.

Address: Water Island Suffolk County, Fire Island, New York

Get to know Water Island
© jonbilous/stock.adobe.com

Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Visit Robert Moses State Park Enjoy the views of the Fire Island Lighthouse Discover the Sunken Forest Have lunch at CJ's Fire Island Dine at SandCastle on The Ocean Visit Smith Point County Park Visit Village of Ocean Beach Get to know Water Island Dine with a view at Maguire's Bayfront Restaurant Visit Sailors' Haven

Explore more: New York Day Trips > Things to Do on Fire Island

Plan Your Trip

Get Ready to Go!

Need some more help?


Go to travel reservations.