• What type of Italian cuisine can you find in Staten Island?
    • Staten Island restaurants specialize in hearty traditional dishes from the Old World or in contemporary Italian food with a twist.
  • Does Staten Island offer more than just Italian food?
    • Yes! The borough also offers restaurants serving a diverse selection of cuisine from all over the world.
  • Are there any notable fine dining options in Staten Island?
    • Staten Island is home to a Michelin star restaurant that makes inspired French-Asian fusion.
  • What other unique dining experiences can you find in Staten Island?
    • The borough features a lively New Orleans-style bistro with a Cajun-Creole menu and regular jazz entertainment, as well as an elegant Chinese restaurant known for its dim sum.

This post may include affiliate links. Click here for Affiliate Disclosure.

1. Angelina's Ristorante


Savor Italian classics and admire waterfront views on a romantic evening out.

Angelina's Ristorante

© Angelina's Ristorante

Tucked away in Tottenville on the tip of Staten Island, Angelina's Ristorante is widely recognized as one of the top fine dining establishments in the Island. The menu offers classic favorites such as chicken breast stuffed with ham and cheese alongside innovative dishes like pistachio encrusted sea bass in limoncello sauce, and plenty of delicious appetizers, salads, and sides can be ordered to accompany your meal. The restaurant is also a popular venue for weddings and other special events, and it rents out private indoor and outdoor spaces that can accommodate between 50 and 250 people.

Angelina's Ristorante, 399 Ellis St, Staten Island, NY 10307, Phone: 718-227-2900

2. Beso


Enjoy Latin fusion dishes and sip creative cocktails in an exciting atmosphere.

Beso

© Beso

Named after the Spanish word for 'kiss', Beso is a romantic Spanish tapas restaurant. It's conveniently located within a ten-minute walk from the ferry, making it an ideal spot to stop when you're running low on time, but the delicious sangria and seafood dishes are worth making a special trip for regardless of whether or not you're in the area. The menu offers both tapas and entrees, and guests can also order one of the delicious daily lunch or dinner specials, which typically include a prix-fixe three-course menu with your choice of tapa, entree, and dessert. Map

3. Blue


Savor fresh seafood and enjoy harbor views during a stylish dinner trip.

Blue

© Blue

A popular Mediterranean restaurant located right on the waterfront, Blue specializes in fresh seafood and Italian-inspired dishes. The menu includes delectable dishes like slow-roasted lamb shank, shrimp topped with crab meat and lobster butter sauce, and sautéed veal cutlets with mushrooms and sherry wine sauce, but the restaurant also offers a four-course menu with an optional unlimited wine, sangria, and beer add-on. Sundays are an especially good time to visit; brunch is offered in the morning, and a fun clambake is available in the afternoon. Both indoor and outdoor dining are available, but reservations are not accepted for the outdoor portion of the restaurant.

Blue, 1115 Richmond Terrace, Staten Island, NY 10310, Phone: 718-273-7777

4. Bocelli


Taste authentic Italian flavors and relax in a cozy, affordable setting.

Bocelli

© Bocelli

An exceptional destination for authentic Italian food, Bocelli prides itself on making delicious food that transports their guests right to a sunny terrace in Italy. The lunch and dinner menus offer everything from raw seafood appetizers to indulgent pasta dishes, and there are special antipasto plates designed for two or more people to share. Wine can be purchased by the glass or by the bottle to accompany your meal. The three-course prix fixe menu offers your choice of appetizer, main, or dessert, and happy hour food and drink specials are available in the bar every weekday between 4 p.m. and 7 p.m.

Bocelli, 1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, Phone: 718-420-6150

5. Cielo Ristorante


Admire elegant décor and enjoy fine Italian cuisine on a weekend date.

Cielo Ristorante

© johny87/stock.adobe.com

Cielo Ristorante was named for the Italian word meaning 'sky', and the delightful cuisine served here will make diners feel like they've flown straight to heaven. The decor is warm and inviting, as is the Italian-inspired menu, which features hearty pasta, fish, and meat dishes alongside fresh salads and soups. A traditional three-course prix fixe menu can be ordered for dinner, and the menu also offers a small selection of vegetarian options. Gluten-free pasta is available upon request. The restaurant is open for both lunch and dinner every day of the week, and catering can be arranged for outside events.

Cielo Ristorante, 1435 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, Phone: 718-668-2211

6. Fiore Di Mare


Dine on Mediterranean seafood and admire scenic water views with couples or friends.

Fiore Di Mare

© Fiore Di Mare

Another of Staten Island's exceptional Italian restaurants, Fiore Di Mare offers an extensive selection of traditional and contemporary dishes. The restaurant is known for its cozy but upscale atmosphere, and guests can choose to dine either inside or out depending on the weather. Offerings include classic fare like ossobuco as well as more innovative dishes like seared Scottish salmon with Israeli cous cous, and there is a prix fixe menu available on weekdays between 3 p.m. and 7 p.m. Visitors should be aware that the prix fixe menu can only be served to groups of six or fewer people.

Fiore Di Mare, 227 Mansion Ave, Staten Island, NY 10308, Phone: 718-227-9771

More Restaurants on Staten Island, New York

Map:


Plan Your Trip


Table of Contents: