Romantic Restaurants in Gettysburg, PA

From its generous portions to its bold Mediterranean flavors, Olivia’s is a go-to spot for anyone craving comforting, made-from-scratch food near Gettysburg. Serving guests since 2005, this family-run gem blends the best of Greek and Italian cuisine, all crafted with a mix of local ingredients and imported staples.

Highlights:

• Fire-grilled New York strip steaks with bourbon glaze or crab imperial
• Homemade Mediterranean dishes like lamb kebabs and Greek-style meatballs
• Generous mezze platters with stuffed grape leaves, eggplant parm, and more
• Fresh, from-scratch cooking with locally sourced ingredients
• Laid-back atmosphere with warm, welcoming service

Menu Must-Try:

The Chesapeake-style steak is a standout—stuffed with crab imperial and grilled to perfection. For something classic, go for the lamb kebabs with zucchini ratatouille or share a mezze platter loaded with Mediterranean favorites.

3015 Baltimore Pike, Gettysburg, PA 17325
Phone: 717-359-9357
www.oliviasgettysburg.com

Located right on charming Lincoln Square, One Lincoln is a great spot for classic American comfort food with a little upscale twist. Opened in 2013 as part of the Gettysburg Hotel’s renovation, this cozy restaurant serves up solid options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner—all led by executive chef Joseph Holmes. Whether you're craving something hearty or just want a chill place to enjoy the view, it’s got you covered.

Highlights:

• Relaxed, family-friendly vibe with views of historic Lincoln Square
• Indoor and outdoor seating
• Comfort food with a creative twist
• Great spot for couples, families, or a casual night out

Menu Must-Try:

The crab mac and cheese is pure comfort in a bowl, but the crab-stuffed scallops and goat cheese ravioli definitely bring the flavor too. Feeling adventurous? Try the seared amaretto duck breast or share some global-inspired apps like curry arancini balls and Asian-style wings.

1 Lincoln Square, Gettysburg, PA 17325
Phone: 717-338-5455
www.onelincoln.net

For a Date

If you’re into creative spins on comfort food, Food 101 is one of Gettysburg’s must-try spots. Opened in 2015 by local restaurateur Don Dantona, this cozy place has earned serious love on TripAdvisor for its locally-sourced ingredients and bold flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for something refined or just grabbing a casual bite, the menu’s full of surprises.

Highlights:

• Fresh, locally-sourced ingredients in every dish
• Top-rated by TripAdvisor diners
• Creative American fare with global inspiration
• Relaxed vibe perfect for lunch or date night

Menu Must-Try:

For dinner, don’t miss the seared Scottish salmon with mandarin white wine sauce or the rack of lamb with orange gastrique and charred feta. Lunchtime is more laid-back—go for the grilled chicken apple panini or the tuna burger with olive tapenade and Dijon mayo.

101 Chambersburg St, Gettysburg, PA 17325
Phone: 717-334-6080
food101gettysburg.com