Right at the far eastern end of Long Island, on the southern shore, sites Montauk. This census-designated place is one of the prettiest little spots in all of New York, stretching out for around 13 miles in total from the edge of Napeague all the way down to Montauk Point Light. Historically used as a military base for the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Coast Guard, Montauk has a rich history and is also home to one of the oldest functioning lighthouses in the entire United States.
Despite its military history, Montauk is best-known nowadays as a major tourist destination, home to some world class fishing and six stunning state parks for all kinds of outdoor recreation. The area features some gorgeous historical architecture and a lot of pretty natural places to explore, so it's no surprise that there are many hotels in Montauk. The area has hotels of all sizes and forms, including charming bed and breakfasts, upscale resorts, gorgeous mansions, beach houses, and more. No matter what kind of accommodation you're looking for in Montauk, you'll be able to find it.
Best Hotels in Montauk, NY
There are dozens of hotels to choose from in Montauk, with something to put a smile on the face of every single visitor. Regardless of your budget or needs, you’ll be able to find the right Montauk hotel to make your stay as enjoyable as possible from the first day to the last. Read on to learn all about the very best hotels in and around Montauk, NY.
- Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa - 290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954 - 631 668-2345)
One of the most popular hotels in the Montauk area, the Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is a full, upscale resort with over 100 rooms, making it one of the biggest hotels in Montauk. It also has some of the finest amenities and features, offering much more than a typical guesthouse or B&B. Fitted out with free spa facilities like a large indoor pool and Roman bath, the Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa provides stylish, modern rooms, many of which also offer exceptional views of the ocean.
This is a beachfront resort with an exclusive sandy beach, so you’ll be able to spend some time sunbathing or swimming and simply walk a few paces to return to the comfort of your room. Guests will also be able to enjoy top class cuisine at the hotel's restaurant, which also looks out onto the ocean, offering a romantic spot to spend an evening. In short, if you're looking for one of the most fully-featured Montauk hotels, this is the best option.
- The Montauk Beach House - 55 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954, Phone: 631-668-2112
The Montauk Beach House is one of the top rated hotels in all of Montauk, with many past guests falling in love with this property at first sight and returning many times again. You'll surely want to do the same after stepping foot into your beautifully decorated room and experiencing the excellent on-site features and amenities of this classy Montauk hotel. Many of the rooms feature high ceilings with traditional features and a very elegant, tasteful type of decor.
The Montauk Beach House is also fitted out with not one, but two swimming pools, along with an open-air bar serving up tasty cocktails and a wide range of other drinks throughout the day. There's also a nice outdoor communal space and a cozy on-site cafe serving up some delicious breakfast treats in the mornings. Naturally, due to the classy nature of this Montauk hotel, prices aren't the cheapest but if you choose your dates carefully, you can get a great deal here.
- The Ocean Resort Inn - 95 S Emerson Ave, Montauk, NY 11954, Phone: 631-668-2300
Right by Montauk Beach, the Ocean Resort Inn can boast of one of the best locations of any Montauk hotel. Being located in such a great spot, you might think that this Montauk hotel comes with some high prices, but the truth is very different: The Ocean Resort Inn is actually one of the best options for budget-conscious travelers in Montauk. It's only a few paces from the soft sands of Long Island but rooms can be reserved for some very attractive prices.
The Ocean Resort Inn offers a nice range of simple, cute rooms with all the amenities and accessories you could need including TVs, microwaves, mini-fridges, good quality bathtubs, and free Wi-Fi throughout. A pool and barbecue grills are located on-site too and the hotel also offers various rentals of beach equipment and bikes. The staff at the Ocean Resort Inn are also said to be very friendly by previous guests, so if you’re looking for a warm welcome at a great price, this is the one to choose.
- Montauk Yacht Club Resort and Marina - 32 Star Island Rd, Montauk, NY 11954, Phone: 631-668-3100
The Montauk Yacht Club Resort and Marina has a rich history, dating back to the 1920s. It's a charming, extensive property with a lot of stories and some truly breathtaking decor. Over 100 rooms are available at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort and Marina, as well as more than 20 villas and a deluxe suite offering awe-inspiring views of the water.
All rooms offer scenic views, large-screen TVs, free internet access, and other amenities, as well as being decorated in a tasteful manner throughout. On-site amenities at this luxury Montauk resort include bike and kayak rentals, a fitness center, beach cabanas, and more. As the 'Marina' part of this hotel's name suggests, guests will also be granted access to the exclusive yacht club marina, holding over 230 slips.